Jan 26, 2018 mastering genealogical proof affiliate link tom jones book in the national genealogical societys special topics series thoroughly covers the genealogical proof standard to include evidence analysis. Citations evidence style genealogy familysearch wiki. Mastering genealogical proof affiliate link tom jones book in the national genealogical societys special topics series thoroughly covers the genealogical proof standard to include evidence analysis. Direct evidence is easier to understand, but indirect evidence can carry equal weight.
The process of genealogical research seeks information facts about events to answer questions research. Genealogy bargains for tuesday, february 19th, 2020. This book is an excellent practical reference guide to current genealogical standards and how to apply them to ones own research. Below ive linked to the evidencebased applications i was able to find under active development, with blurbs from their web sites describing their applications. Linda kent the lindsay post this book is an excellent practical reference guide to current genealogical standards and how to apply them to ones own research. Apr 09, 2020 the genealogical proof standard gps was created by the board for certification of genealogists. The book aims to help researchers, students, and new family historians reconstruct relationships and lives of people they cannot see.
However, direct evidence doesnt mean that the answer is correct. That includes why some people turn their nose up at them. Anyone who wants to become a certified genealogist will need to read this book. Conclusions which meet the five elements of the genealogical proof standard will generally continue to hold as true, even if new evidence is uncovered.
Ive been studying genealogy standards, a book published by the board for certification of genealogists to better understand the different parts of analysis. Explain how to evaluate evidence found in books, an easy starting place to practice your new skill. Jones in his book mastering genealogical proof offers the. According to the book, two of these groups originated from ancient israel. The chicago manual of style gives many examples of citations for different published sources.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading genealogical standards of evidence. This work examines the simple model evidence analysis. Stevenons book is a compelling, if a bit dense, challenge to genealogists to be sure that what they claim can be substantiated witha preponderance of evidence. The understanding of joseph smith and of traditional mormonism is that the book of mormon reveals that the american indians are descendants of the lamanites, who descended from lehi and are therefore a remnant of the house of israel. Primary focus on original records not treated in traditional guides 9 chapters 532 pp. Jul 26, 2001 an oftcited source that contradicts this assertion is an extensive study of the history of wallingford, connecticut written by charles henry stanley davis, m. Genealogy bargains is the best site to save money on. As a rule, direct evidence is preferred to indirect evidence, although indirect evidence, carefully constructed, could indeed outweigh direct.
One citation style used by genealogical and historical researchers is evidence style, developed by elizabeth shown mills. Evidence should be drawn from a variety of independently created sources. The enormous success of the book was followed by a television adaptation in 1977 that was nothing short of a national media event. The book of mormon, the founding document of the latter day saint movement and one of the four books of scripture of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church, is an account of three groups of people.
The dark side of our genealogy craze the washington post. Genealogical proof standard visual guide genealogy. Davis was a noted genealogist of his day who began compiling materials for the 957page book in 1858. What youll learn from this book will undoubtedly shape your research strategies in the future. Nicole is the publicity chair at the pima county genealogy society. Evidence explained is the answer to a genealogists quest for citation guidelines. A genealogists guide and author of find names for the temple. A fresh set of expert eyes can help you identify the problem, and recommend the sources you need to pursue in order to compile trustworthy evidence. Evidence explained is the guide everyone should own. Easier source citation with your genealogy software.
Evidence explained guides us through a maze of sources not covered by other citation manualsall kinds of original records, accessed through various media. Read kates article genealogical evidence and proof. This new edition of the official manual from the board of certification for genealogists provides a standard by which all genealogists can pattern their work. Evidence explained defines proof as a conclusion based upon the sum of the evidence that supports a valid assertion or deduction i. The couple may have been born 16 or 60 years earlier. What is the genealogical proof standard and why should you. A fresh set of expert eyes can help you identify the problem, and recommend the sources you need to pursue. The genealogical proof standard gps was created by the board for certification of genealogists. A fresh set of expert eyes can help you identify the problem and recommend the sources you. Source original record, derivative record, or authored narrative information primary, secondary, or undetermined evidence direct, indirect, or negative.
Citing history sources from artifacts to cyberspace, 2d ed. The records you have found provide evidence relative to your objective. Centurial, unlike some of the few other evidencebased genealogy programs, is not intended as a companion application to conclusionbased software progams. Researchers compare existing genetic evidence with the book of mormon story. Nicole dyer is a professional genealogist, lecturer, and creator of and the research like a pro genealogy podcast. Im going to start by explaining why you should be using books in genealogy research. Genealogical evidence analysis tool an algorithmic.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Apr 06, 2020 a fresh set of eyes on your genealogy brick wall. Such tools should begin appearing in next generation genealogy. Those standards are set forth in two books by elizabeth shown mills, both from genealogical. How to know if youve compiled enough evidence at the genealogy gems blog. Doing a genealogy research project from start to finish. Why the revised third edition of evidence explained, by. Genealogists use oral interviews, historical records, genetic analysis, and other records to obtain information about a family and to demonstrate kinship and pedigrees of its members. Jul 08, 2019 her work on the subject can be read in quicklesson 17.
There is generally no direct support amongst mainstream historians and. In successful genealogical research, these two practices are inseparable, and the authors treatment of this littleunderstood concept is nothing. Apr 07, 2020 read kates article genealogical evidence and proof. Evaluating evidence in genealogy collecting cousins. The family tree guide to dna testing and genetic genealogy by blaine t. Evaluating the evidence for genealogy research mishawaka. How much merit is assigned to each piece of evidence will be dependent on the reliability of the. Ngs family history conference writing a conclusion. Its used to create sound, credible genealogical proof statements, and gives genealogists a standard to measure conclusions against.
Evaluating evidence in your genealogy research amy. Elizabeth shown mills is a wellregarded, nationally ranked genealogy lecturer and author. The first article in this threepart series will provide an overview of the evidence analysis process and discuss the concept of sources in genealogy. Check out my post 5 things to ask about genealogy information for tips on how to evaluate that. Evaluating evidence in your genealogy research amy johnson crow.
A guide for family historians 2 by brenda dougall merriman 2010, paperback at the best online prices at ebay. Heavy in weight, thick in size, and rich in content. The special topics series titles are workbooks that give the opportunity to answer questions and practice your skills. With the everexpanding internet databases and records collections, it is becoming more and more important for serious genealogists to understand how to properly cite these sources. Any genealogist using dna as evidence for a genealogical conclusion can benefit from the ideas and experiences of article writers and book authors that will be included in this session. Genealogy standards, second edition 2019 board for. Such tools should begin appearing in next generation genealogy programs. Jan 28, 2019 when collecting and analyzing the evidence to prove your case, it is important first to understand how genealogists use sources, information, and evidence. This book is a mustread for budding genetic genealogists and dna veterans alike. In the introduction to the book davis explains that he performed his. The worldgenweb project is a nonprofit, volunteer based organization dedicated to providing genealogical and historical records and.
A guide for family historians genealogists reference shelf book 2 kindle edition by merriman, brenda dougall. It is highly recommended for a researchers personal collection. A fresh set of expert eyes can help you identify the problem and recommend the sources you need. Its not as easy as yes or no, but its not that hard once you follow the tested process for evaluating evidence.
Mastering genealogical proof guides readers in acquiring genealogical skills transcending chronological, ethnic, geopolitical, and religious boundaries. Dont leave any stone unturned, and look in every place that might have information on the person or people youre researching. A template for evaluating evidence genealogical computing. Instead, it is intended as a replacement of these programs, offering all of the nice diagrams and insight of traditional genealogy software, all evidencebased. Save 40% on 12month subscription packages at findmypast. Genealogical evidence analysis tool an algorithmic research. Free webinar newspapers for people of color genealogy research. Genealogy evidence analysis free template and lucinda. When collecting and analyzing the evidence to prove your case, it is important first to understand how genealogists use sources, information, and evidence. For example, a marriage record is evidence that a couple was born, but unless it gives the age of the bride or groom, you can only guess at their birth dates. Citing history sources from artifacts to cyberspace. The evidence analysis process model and in her book evidence explained.
Evidence explained citing history sources from artifacts to cyberspace third edition revised. In general the applications available for doing evidencebased genealogy seem to be intended as companion apps to traditional conclusionbased apps like those mentioned above. A template for evaluating evidence genealogical computing 24 apriljune 2004 extracted from unpaginated archived copy. May 10, 2018 however, direct evidence doesnt mean that the answer is correct. The genealogical proof standard and record reliability when using the genealogical proof standard, you will want to examine every possible record source regarding your ancestor or family line.
Evidence analysis starts with a three step classification 1 the type of information 2 the type of evidence and 3 the type of source. Jul 07, 2016 ive been studying genealogy standards, a book published by the board for certification of genealogists to better understand the different parts of analysis. Mills critical evaluation of your genealogical research to date. Reliable genealogical conclusions are based on the weighnot quantityof the evidence found. A guide for family historians by brenda dougall merriman is a must for the serious genealogist. Sometimes the wrong evidence or assumptions can push us into a brick wall. Free webinar newspapers for people of color genealogy research presented by nicka smith, wednesday, february 19th, 2020 via legacy family tree. Dec, 2019 although such evidence bears no relevance to the ways that tribes consider inclusion and enrollment, warrens dna test illustrated how the scientific evidence of ancestry could bolster the. The book even has a glossary of dna terms that simplifies important dna concepts, plus a chapter that busts common misconceptions about genetic testing. Applying the principles discussed in this book is like having mrs.
Because i love a good visual, i created this process flowchart to walk you through proper genealogical research. Genealogical proof standard visual guide genealogy explained. Debbie is the editor of the newly released march 2019 book advanced genetic genealogy. Why the revised third edition of evidence explained, by elizabeth shown mills is a musthave for your book shelf. In successful genealogical research, these two practices are inseparable, and the authors treatment of this littleunderstood concept is nothing short of brilliant.
John as a bondsman, then the evidence we draw from this source and its information i. Database descriptions on, and other genealogy websites usually state the source of the data, but these bibliographic references are often not written in a consistent formator one that follows accepted genealogical citation standards. Her work on the subject can be read in quicklesson 17. A template for evaluating evidence genealogical computing 24.
An oftcited source that contradicts this assertion is an extensive study of the history of wallingford, connecticut written by charles henry stanley davis, m. Indirect often called circumstantial evidence usually requires additional evidence to prove a fact. Genealogy standards second edition, paperback or kindle ebook available through amazon. This excellent discussion by an acclaimed attorney and fellow of the american society of genealogists forms the basis for evaluating genealogical evidence. In successful genealogical research, these two practices are inseparable. Genealogy standards, fiftiethanniversary edition 2014 board for. It is an extension of the notesbibliography system from the chicago manual of style. You have to evaluate the underlying information for accuracy. The importance of establishing proof and the genealogical proof. Centurial, unlike some of the few other evidence based genealogy programs, is not intended as a companion application to conclusionbased software progams. In successful genealogical research, these two practices are inseparable, and the authors treatment of this. It provides little guidance for the many different types of manuscript. Jul 08, 20 in general the applications available for doing evidencebased genealogy seem to be intended as companion apps to traditional conclusionbased apps like those mentioned above.